Abstract
Urban journeys of approximately 20 to 50km are inadequately served by existing public transport. Both existing metro and suburban rail are subject to geographical limitations, whereas existing road transport networks are largely limited by congestion. This report develops SkyCoach, a concept for a modular electric vertical takeoff and landing passenger service operating on scheduled routes between hubs situated at existing public transport interchanges. A hierarchical task analysis of the passenger journey was utilised to establish system requirements, each of which was benchmarked against published NASA, FAA and EASA material and against current eVTOL programmes. Five subsystem studies were conducted to address mission requirements, propulsion architecture, energy source and storage, safety and certification, and cabin design and accessibility. The resultant concept specifies a lift/cruise distributed electric propulsion aircraft powered by a hydrogen fuel cell with exchangeable solid state hydride storage, carrying four interchangeable cabin modules of four passenger equivalents each. Passengers select a module configuration through a journey planning application, which returns the arrival time of the next coach carrying the required configuration. Three principal findings are reported. First, the operating concept of scheduled routes makes turnaround the primary design constraint, where exchangeable cartridges separate turnaround from recharge rate. Second, a wingless multicopter architecture cannot achieve the cruise speed and range necessary for medium range journeys; therefore, a lift/cruise configuration is adopted despite its comparably greater mechanical complexity. Third, the principal barriers to adoption are economic and regulatory: the competitiveness of fares against existing metro fares, and the absence of a certification basis for scheduled passenger operations within dense urban areas. The concept is assessed as plausible at technology readiness expected beyond 2040, as it is dependent on the maturation of solid state hydrogen storage and on the establishment of an urban corridor airspace framework.
Abbreviation and Nomenclature Lists
| Abbreviation | Description |
| AAM | Advanced Air Mobility |
| BLI | Boundary-Layer Ingestion |
| CASTLE | Cabin System Design Towards Passenger Wellbeing |
| DEP | Distributed Electric Propulsion |
| DP | Distributed Propulsion |
| EASA | European Union Aviation Safety Agency |
| EVTOL | Electric Vertical Take-Off and Landing |
| FAA | Federal Aviation Administration |
| FEM | Finite Element Modelling |
| HEFA | Hydroprocessed Esters and Fatty Acids |
| HMI | Human-Machine Interface |
| HTA | Hierarchical Task Analysis |
| MOC | Means Of Compliance |
| NASA | National Aeronautics and Space Administration |
| SAF | Sustainable Aviation Fuel |
| SC-VTOL | Special Condition for VTOL aircraft |
| TRL | Technology Readiness Level |
| UAM | Urban Air Mobility |
| VTOL | Vertical Take-Off and Landing |
Table I. Abbreviation list.
| Symbol | Description | Unit |
| dBA | A-weighted sound pressure level | decibel |
| A/mm² | Electrical current density | ampere per square millimetre |
| km/h | Speed | kilometre per hour |
| mph | Speed | mile per hour |
| °C | Temperature | degree Celsius |
| ‡ | Illustrative placeholder value | — |
Table II. Nomenclature list.
1. Introduction (AR)
Existing urban transport systems address both short journeys and long journeys effectively. Nevertheless, journeys of approximately 20 to 50km across or between urban areas see a comparative lack of sufficient service, as they are excessive for bus travel, overly dispersed for an efficient metro network and face congestion on road. Still, they determine the practical distance between residence and employment, constituting a gap in existing public transport.
One proposed response is advanced air mobility. NASA describes urban air mobility, a subset of AAM, as a future transportation concept intended to provide rapid transport within metropolitan areas through integrating air travel into existing transportation networks [1][2]. The FAA anticipates AAM operations connecting multiple locations through airports, heliports and vertiports, and encourages that vertiports connect several transport systems through intermodal siting [3][4]. Current commercial urban air travel models predominantly comprise four-seat air taxis addressing the premium travel market with high fares to compensate for a low frequency of usage and high maintenance costs.
SkyCoach applies an alternative operating model, where aircraft operate continuously around scheduled loops, similarly to a bus or metro line, between hubs located at existing surface and metro interchanges. Capacity is provided by several interchangeable modules carried by each coach, comprising high density seating, wheelchair accessible and cargo configurations, combined in varying arrangements across the coaches operating each loop. A passenger states their requirements in a journey planning application, which returns the arrival time of the next coach carrying a suitable configuration. The intended outcome combines the speed of an aircraft with the predictability and unit economics of conventional public transport.
This report defines the concept at system level with a limited scope, where no detailed technical design is undertaken, no certification case is presented, and no geographically specific network is proposed. The report presents a set of passenger requirements, a selection of propulsion architecture and energy source, an identification of the safety constraints governing routine operations above urban areas, and a declaration of the matters that remain unresolved.
Values marked with a double dagger (‡) are illustrative figures adopted to demonstrate the structure of the argument. They are consistent with the sources cited but have not been derived by calculation.
2. Aims and Objectives (AR)
2.1 Aims
To conceptually define a technically coherent and publicly acceptable eVTOL scheduled transportation system for medium range urban travel, and to assess whether this system could complement an existing transportation network.
2.2 Objectives
- To establish system level requirements from a hierarchical task analysis of the passenger journey.
- To evaluate existing eVTOL propulsion architectures against those requirements and to select one.
- To evaluate existing energy sources and storage methods against the selected architecture and against turnaround requirements.
- To establish the constraints of the concept for operation within urban areas and hence establish required design features.
- To establish a modular cabin concept, which addresses user requirements.
- To assess the principal barriers to public acceptance.
- To establish the consistency of the five subsystem studies and hence to establish a resultant proposal, and to identify the assumptions upon which that consistency depends.
3. Methodology (AR, RA)
3.1 Hierarchical task analysis
The study was based on a hierarchical task analysis of the complete passenger journey. The root task is task “0. Complete a journey in a SkyCoach EVTOL”, where top level parents describe journey planning, module reservation, travel to the interchange, boarding, flight, landing and disembarkation.
Figure 1. Fragment of the first-level SkyCoach HTA branches showing the end-to-end passenger journey.
3.2 Requirement register framework
A requirement was established where a HTA task created a need that must be satisfied at the system level. Each requirement therefore referred to an individual HTA task, and each was assigned an assessable target by reference to an external aviation source. This procedure allowed all requirements to be traced to passenger need and allowed the requirement register to be audited, since any requirement lacking a task reference constituted an assumption.
3.3 Source benchmarking
Three classes of source were used, in descending order of authority. Regulatory material, primarily the EASA Special Condition for VTOL aircraft [17] and its associated means of compliance [18], together with FAA AAM planning documents [3][4][9][12], was used to establish binding requirements. Agency research, primarily NASA technical reports [1][2][7][8][10][13], was used to establish current assessments of feasibility and of open problems. Peer-reviewed journal articles [14][16][19-23][28-30] were used to obtain quantitative results at the subsystem level.
3.4 Comparator programme benchmarking
Joby Aviation [5] and Archer Aviation [6] were used as feasibility benchmarks, being the most advanced passenger eVTOL programmes with published performance figures, both being four-seat air taxis. Such figures therefore bind the performance achievable by a single cabin and do not bind the performance of multiple cabins. Hence, in this report they are applied only to parameters at the module level.
3.5 Trade study method
Trade studies were determined to be necessary for selections for propulsion architecture, energy source and cabin seating layout. In each case the criteria was taken from the requirements register, so that the selection is determined by the mission. Options were scored qualitatively as favourable, neutral or unfavourable against each criterion. Any option assessed as unfavourable against a requirement classified as binding was excluded. Weightings were agreed by the full team before scoring and are recorded in Appendix D.
4. Results and Discussion
4.1 System level requirements (RA, AR)
4.1.1 Mission requirements
Considering the HTA root task and its top-level parents, the aircraft is to operate as one element of a scheduled transportation network. NASA operational concept literature describes passenger UAM as part of the existing transportation system [1][2], and FAA planning anticipates vertiports situated to connect multiple transport modes [3][4].
M1. SkyCoach shall provide repeatable scheduled passenger transport between hub pairs and shall be capable of vertical take-off and landing for operation within the planned AAM vertiport network.
4.1.2 Capacity requirement
Task 1.4 of the HTA requires the system to identify group size, with subtasks establishing passenger count, children, passengers who must remain together, companions and service animals. Similarly, Task 3.2 requires the necessary module capacity to be identified and cross-referenced against set module capacities before a module is selected. The terminology assumed by these tasks must be defined before a capacity figure can be stated.
A module is an interchangeable cabin unit with a defined configuration. A coach is the vehicle frame, which carries several modules. The comparator aircraft is then used to define requirements for capacity of modules. Both Joby and Archer Midnight are configured to carry four passengers and a pilot [5][6]; hence, a module seating four passenger equivalents is selected, as it is the largest cabin unit for which an equivalent flying vehicle has been demonstrated.
Figure 2. HTA tasks used to establish group-size and journey-time requirements.
Figure 3. HTA module-selection branch, covering task 3.2 and subtask 3.2.4.
C1. Each SkyCoach module shall hold four passenger equivalents.
C2. The baseline SkyCoach shall carry four passenger modules yielding a capacity of 16 passenger equivalents ‡ in a maximum seating configuration, which is reduced if wheelchair or cargo modules are fitted. The passenger-equivalent unit is applied throughout the study. A wheelchair space, a cargo space and four seats each occupy one module, which allows for modules to be interchanged and allows the scheduled loops to remain fixed under any varied configuration.
4.1.3 Speed and range requirement
HTA tasks 1.2, 1.2.4 and 1.2.5 require the passenger to identify a required arrival time, an acceptable arrival time and any additional time needed after arrival. Hence, the vehicle must provide sufficient speed and range to satisfy arrival time requirements including ground legs. Improvements in cruise speed consequently produce a less than proportionate reduction in total journey time.
NASA identifies reduced travel time as a primary benefit of AAM, as passengers travel across a city or between neighbouring urban areas by more direct routes [7]. Archer reports a top speed of up to 150mph, a range of up to 100 miles and optimisation for repeated sectors of approximately 20 miles [6]. Joby reports speeds up to 200mph [5]. Hence, 150mph is a reasonable cruise speed target without assuming characteristics not yet demonstrated.
S1. SkyCoach shall have a target cruise speed of approximately 240km/h (150mph)
R1. SkyCoach shall be optimised for typical sectors of 32 to 48km (20 to 30 miles) and shall provide a maximum range capability of approximately 160km (100 miles), allowing for regular service distances and potential diversions.
4.1.4 Turnaround and service frequency requirement
The HTA requires a passenger exchange before departure for each service cycle, where task 10.2 encompasses disembarking passengers exiting and task 10.3 describes passengers settling into the module. To facilitate an efficient scheduled service, this ground interval must be constrained. NASA vertiport studies identify turnaround time as a governing factor in scheduling, sequencing and spacing [8], and FAA planning identifies AAM infrastructure as required to support several aircraft flying frequently over short sectors [9]. Archer provides an industry benchmark of consecutive sectors of 20 miles with approximately ten minutes of charging between them [6].
Figure 4. HTA boarding and departure sequence used to determine turnaround requirements.
T1. For standard sectors, SkyCoach shall achieve a total ground turnaround of no more than 15 minutes between arrival and readiness for the next departure.
F1. Each loop shall be operated at a headway of no more than ten minutes ‡ during peak periods, an interval that permits passengers to arrive without consulting a timetable.
Requirement F1 distinguishes the SkyCoach model from a taxi model but consequently introduces numerous secondary constraints. A set headway on a loop with a set number of hubs determines the fleet size, determining the number of ground positions required at each hub, which in turn constrains the footprint of a hub. These consequences are further examined in Section 4.7.
4.1.5 Noise requirement
The HTA requires repeated service cycles near interchanges. Since these operations occur repeatedly above populated areas, noise production is a primary limiting factor of both public and legal acceptance as a regular public transport network. NASA describes community response to noise as a significant challenge for AAM acceptance [10], and FAA planning describes noise as an environmental and community acceptance issue [11]. The FAA currently applies existing aircraft noise regulations to powered lift aircraft and lacks a separate universal eVTOL limit [12]. Hence, no A-weighted value can be presented as a legal requirement. Joby describes a design baseline of 45dBA in cruise measured at 500m and 65dBA on landing measured at 100m [5].
N1. SkyCoach shall comply with applicable powered lift noise requirements and shall minimise external noise during operations near populated areas to approximately 45dBA in cruise at 500m and 65dBA on landing at 100m as target benchmarks.
4.1.6 Network integration, accessibility and passenger information requirement
The following requirements define SkyCoach as a scheduled public transport system. Each is traceable to a HTA task, and each imposes constraints additional to those imposed by the aircraft level requirements.
I1. Hubs shall be co-located with major surface or metro interchanges, with a vertical transfer time between platform and departure gate of no more than 5 minutes ‡.
Mo1. Any standard module shall be installable on any coach, and a module exchange shall be achievable in no more than eight minutes ‡ consistent with T1.
A1. At least one wheelchair-accessible module shall be available on each loop at intervals of no more than 20 minutes ‡ throughout operating hours. Accessibility shall be provided by an integral ramp, requested through a call mechanism identified at HTA task 14.7.1.
D1. The journey planning application shall present the arrival time of the next coach carrying a module configuration matching the passenger’s stated requirements, as established at HTA tasks 1.4 and 3.2.
P1. SkyCoach shall operate under supervised autonomy with one safety attendant on board and with a ground operator able to intervene. This arrangement is assessed against passenger acceptance in Section 4.6.1 and against certification requirements in Section 4.4.
4.1.7 Requirements register
| ID | Requirement | Target or criterion | HTA basis | Evidence |
| M1 | Mission | Scheduled VTOL passenger transport between assigned hub pairs | 0; top level parents | [1-4] |
| C1 | Module capacity | 4 passenger equivalents | 1.4; 1.4.1-1.4.6; 3.2 | [5][6] |
| C2 | Coach capacity | 4 modules; 16 passenger nominal ‡ | 1.4; 3.2 | Derived |
| S1 | Cruise speed | ~240km/h (150mph) | 1.2; 1.2.4; 1.2.5 | [6][7] |
| R1 | Range | 32-48km typical; 160km capability | 1.2; 1.2.5 | [6] |
| T1 | Turnaround | ≤15 min arrival to departure readiness | 10.2; 10.3 | [6][8][9] |
| F1 | Headway | ≤10 min at peak ‡ | 1.1; 1.2 | [8][9] |
| Mo1 | Module exchange | ≤8 min ‡; any module, any coach | 3.2; 3.2.4 | Derived |
| A1 | Accessibility | Accessible module ≤20 min interval ‡ | 14.7.1 | Derived |
| I1 | Intermodal siting | Hub on interchange; transfer ≤5 mins ‡ | 1.3 | [3][4] |
| D1 | Passenger information | Next matching configuration shown in application | 1.4; 3.2 | Dervied |
| N1 | Noise | Comply; target 45dBA cruise at 500m | Repeated cycle | [5][10-12] |
| P1 | Crewing | Supervised autonomy; one attendant | 12.3; 12.4 | [17] |
| E1 | Energy | Hydrogen fuel cell; no in-flight CO2 | Concept objective | [31][33] |
Table 1. SkyCoach system-level requirements register.
4.1.8 Requirement traceability
| HTA task or need | System implication | Decision taken | Evidence |
| 0 complete a journey | Aircraft forms part of an end-to-end chain | Hub-to-hub scheduled VTOL mission | [1-4] |
| 1.4 group size; 3.2 module capacity | Capacity determined before module selection | 4 passenger module; 4 module coach | [5][6] |
| 1.2 required arrival time | Air segment must produce a material time saving | 240km/h cruise target | [6][7] |
| 1.2 journey completion | Sector flown without immediate stop | 32-48km typical; 160km capability | [6] |
| 10.2, 10.3 passenger exchange | Exchange must fit a repeatable cycle | ≤15 min turnaround; cartridge exchange | [6][8][9] |
| Repeated departure and landing | External noise must be controlled | Compliance and 45dBA design target | [5][10-12] |
| 14.7.1 wheelchair request | Step-free access on deman | Accessible module at ≤20 min interval ‡ | Derived |
Table 2. Traceability from HTA task to design decision.
4.2 Propulsion architecture (DV, AR)
4.2.1 Distributed electric propulsion
Distributed electric propulsion is a subset of distributed propulsion, in which thrust is produced by several propulsors and in which power reaches those propulsors electrically [13]. Propulsors are not mechanically linked with the power source and can hence be arranged according to aerodynamic considerations. SkyCoach applies this property in the configuration selected below.
Figure 5. Principal electric propulsion system architectures for aircraft.
Most current eVTOL designs adopt fully electric propulsion for its simplicity, absence of local emissions, low noise and high energy conversion efficiency [14]. SkyCoach uses an all-electric propulsion system in this sense. The method of electricity generation is addressed in Section 4.3.
4.2.2 Aerodynamic consequences of distribution
Integration of propulsors with the airframe permits aero-propulsive coupling. Two primary effects of this are considered. First, boundary-layer ingestion allows propulsors to take in the slow-moving air adjacent to the fuselage, improving propulsive efficiency [14], and studies incorporating BLI in propulsion system design have demonstrated substantial reductions in energy use [15]. Second, propulsor placement can reduce airframe drag. Both effects favour a configuration incorporating a wing and forward-facing cruise propulsors.
4.2.3 Thermal management and the hover penalty
Thermal management requires a trade between weight and power. Liquid-cooled motors achieve at least twice the power density of air-cooled motors, but pumps and coolant add mass and introduce potential leak weak points. Air cooling offers an advantage in eVTOL applications as the vehicle operates in its own slipstream [14]. Current density is presently limited to approximately 10A/mm².
Figure 6. Current density limits under different cooling methods.
The more significant constraint is the hover energy penalty. Analysis of tilt-optimised rotor eVTOLs indicates that hover consumes approximately six times more energy per minute than cruise [16]. In hover, all lift is produced by the rotors, with no contribution from a wing. Any architecture that flies its complete mission in that condition incurs the penalty throughout the mission.
Figure 7. Time and energy consumed in the hover and cruise mission segments.
4.2.4 Selection of architecture
Four architectures are available: rotorcraft, multicopter, lift-plus-cruise and vectored thrust [14]. They were scored against the binding performance requirements S1 and R1, against N1 and against complexity.
| Architecture | Hover | Cruise speed and range | Noise | Complexity | Verdict |
| Rotorcraft | Favourable | Unfavourable: rotor limited | Unfavourable | Favourable | Rejected |
| Multicopter | Neutral | Unfavourable: no wing, S1 and R1 unment | Neutral | Favourable | Rejected |
| Lift-plus-cruise | Neutral | Favourable: wing-borne cruise | Favourable | Neutral | Selected |
| Vectored thrust | Neutral | Favourable | Neutral | Unfavourable | Reserve option |
Table 3. Four architectures scored against S1, R1, N1 and complexity.
The multicopter architecture offers redundancy through eight to 18 identical lift units, along with offering mechanical simplicity. It was nevertheless rejected. In the absence of a wing, the hover-order energy penalty applies throughout flight, and the resulting designs achieve cruise speeds and ranges of approximately one half and one quarter of S1 and R1 respectively, and it is impossible to refine a wingless configuration to close that margin.
Lift-plus-cruise was therefore selected, where lift rotors perform vertical phases of flight while wing and cruise propulsors perform the majority of the journey, satisfying S1 and R1 and confining the noisiest condition to the beginning and end of each sector. The penalty is that the lift rotors constitute inactive mass in cruise and the cruise propulsors constitute inactive mass in hover. Vectored thrust avoids that penalty through reuse of the same propulsors and is retained as a reserve option, but its tilting mechanisms introduce single points of failure in the flight-critical path that are difficult to reconcile with the failure tolerance required in Section 4.4.2.
In conclusion, the selected architecture is lift-plus-cruise distributed electric propulsion, with air-cooled motors, redundant lift units and cruise propulsors positioned to exploit boundary-layer ingestion where the final airframe layout permits.
4.3 Energy source and storage (LM, AR)
4.3.1 Candidate sources
Three candidates were considered as options for energy sources: sustainable aviation fuel, lithium-ion batteries and hydrogen. Since SkyCoach operates repeatedly at low altitude above populated areas, lifecycle carbon intensity and local emissions were weighted alongside the performance criteria. SAF may be produced by four principal pathways, of which the electrochemical route achieves the highest lifecycle CO2 reduction at approximately 95% and HEFA the highest energy efficiency at approximately 70% [31]. The decisive weakness for this application is structural. Current supply is largely limited and is already exceeded by commercial aviation; therefore, reliable access for an urban transport operator cannot be reasonably assumed.
Lithium-ion batteries offer largely straightforward integration, since electric propulsors can be driven directly from an integrated battery pack to provide quiet flight without major emissions using a technology which is already widely utilised and researched. However, three major limitations apply to this source. Fast charging within a five to 15 minute turnaround is approaching the absolute limit of capability of currently available technology. Additionally, repeated fast charging introduces degradation through lithium plating, which reduces potential capacity and lifespan, as well as greatly increasing the risk of thermal runaway [32]. Specific energy remains insufficient for the required medium range journeys with reserves. Lastly, the chemical composition of battery packs’ chemistry introduces broader problems in the production chain, specifically cobalt, which conflicts with the environmentally conscious philosophy of the proposed concept.
Hydrogen provides approximately three times the specific energy of gasoline by mass, but substantially less by volume. This transfers the principal difficulty of using this source from the powerplant to the storage system. However, the conversion of hydrogen produces no carbon dioxide, and the system is carbon-neutral overall where the hydrogen is produced by electrolysis powered by renewable generation [33]. Its flammability and the conditions required for conventional storage present safety considerations that must be addressed explicitly, since public perception of hydrogen will influence acceptance independently of the engineering case.
Figure 8. Hydrogen production methods and their respective energy sources.
4.3.2 Selection of source
| Criterion | SAF | Lithium-ion battery | Hydrogen fuel cell |
| Specific energy | Favourable | Unfavourable | Favourable |
| Turnaround (T1) | Favourable | Unfavourable | Favourable with exchange |
| In-flight CO2 | Neutral: 85-95% lifecycle | Favourable | Favourable |
| Supply security | Unfavourable | Neutral | Neutral |
| Technology readiness | Favourable | Favourable | Unfavourable |
| Verdict | Rejected | Rejected | Selected |
Table 4. Energy source trade study.
Hydrogen was selected. The selection criterion weighted long-term potential and lifecycle emissions above near-term technology readiness, which is appropriate to a concept study for a service that does not yet exist and inappropriate to a procurement decision.
4.3.3 Candidate storage
Storage presents the principal design challenge. Compressed gas tanks occupy volume unavailable within a modular cabin layout and require high-pressure equipment. Cryogenic storage offers higher density but requires continuous cooling and dedicated ground infrastructure. Consequently, neither method suits an aircraft that is reconfigured between services.
Figure 9. Compressed (a) and cryogenic (b) hydrogen storage arrangements.
Solid-state storage addresses both constraints. H2GO Power developed a porous material capable of chemically trapping hydrogen at room temperature and ambient pressure, releasing it on heating to approximately 80°C, with the released hydrogen supplied to a fuel cell for conversion to electrical power [34]. The company has ceased operation, and this method of storage is thus regarded primarily as a theoretical assumption for future capabilities. Regardless, this method holds great operational significance for the vehicle, as it stores hydrogen in solid form, which allows cells to be exchanged. Hence, refuelling the vehicle would constitute only exchanging fuel cells, and turnaround rates would become independent from charging rates.
4.3.4 Consequences for turnaround
Under a battery architecture, turnaround is restricted by charge rate, and T1 at 15 minutes with a 10-minute headway is achievable only at the cost of fast-charging degradation [32]. Under cartridge exchange, turnaround is bound by the mechanical exchange time specified in Mo1 at 8 minutes ‡ and by passenger exchange. Both quantities are controlled by the operator and are improvable through hub design.
E1. SkyCoach shall be powered by a hydrogen fuel cell supplying the distributed electric propulsion system, with solid-state hydride cartridges exchanged during turnaround. Hydrogen shall be sourced by electrolysis from renewable generation where available.
The dependency created by this decision is stated in Section 5. A sensitivity case in which exchange technology does not mature, requiring reversion to batteries with an extended headway and a reduced sector length, is outlined in Appendix D.
4.4 Safety, certification and hazard management (AC, AR)
4.4.1 Certification basis
An eVTOL operating repeatedly above populated areas must remain safe for its occupants and for persons beneath its route. The EASA Special Condition for VTOL aircraft [17] provides the most developed framework, and its two operational categories are directly relevant. Category Enhanced requires continued safe flight and landing following a failure. Category Basic requires a controlled emergency landing. Since SkyCoach operates scheduled services above dense urban areas, Category Enhanced is adopted as the target throughout this section.
4.4.2 Failure tolerance and redundancy
SkyCoach depends on multiple electric motors, propellers, flight control computers and electrical systems. The certification framework for higher-safety VTOL operations requires that no single failure produce a catastrophic effect [17]. In practice, the loss of one lift unit must leave sufficient control authority and power for continued flight to a hub or for a controlled landing, which determines the minimum number of lift units and constrains their arrangement. The lift-plus-cruise architecture selected in Section 4.2 provides independent failure paths for the lift and cruise functions.
4.4.3 Emergency landing and occupant protection
EASA requires that occupants be protected against injury that would prevent egress under the inertia loads likely in an emergency landing, that occupant protection systems create no secondary hazard and do not impede egress, and that baggage and cargo be retained so that they neither strike occupants nor damage systems required for a controlled landing [17]. The full provisions are reproduced in Appendix C.
These provisions have direct consequences for the modular cabin. Restraint design, mass retention and egress paths must be certified for each module and must remain valid in every permitted combination of modules, which presents a more demanding case than a fixed cabin. The cargo module is the governing case, since it places a large secured mass adjacent to occupied modules, and its retention must be demonstrated at emergency landing load factors.
A public transport service carries passengers of varied age, physical ability and familiarity with aircraft, few of whom will have received a briefing. Evacuation must therefore be designed for an untrained population. Draft procedures derived from HTA branches 12 and 14 are provided in Appendix C. The design requirements they impose are a cabin call mechanism reachable from every seat position, crew-directed sequential disembarkation and automated announcements that do not depend on the attendant being reachable.
4.4.4 Hydrogen fire safety
Lithium-ion systems present a risk of thermal runaway in a damaged or defective cell, producing extreme heat, fire and potentially toxic gases, and EASA requires manufacturers to demonstrate containment of battery failures. Solid-state hydride storage reduces that specific hazard, since hydrogen is chemically bound at ambient pressure and requires heating to approximately 80°C for release [34], so a damaged cartridge presents no pressurised or cryogenic release path.
Fire risk is not eliminated. The fuel cell, its hydrogen delivery path and the cartridge heating system introduce additional failure modes. EASA requires means to isolate and mitigate hazards arising from a lift or thrust system fire or overheat condition, together with established operating limitations, markings, inspection requirements and energy-level information supporting energy management [17]. Three design measures follow. Cartridge bays shall be isolated from occupied modules. Hydrogen detection shall be fitted at the fuel cell, the delivery path and the exchange interface. The hub exchange operation shall be treated as a fuelling operation for ground fire protection purposes, with the associated separation distances and detection provision. Hub fire provision is examined further in Section 4.7.
4.4.5 Bird strike
Bird strike presents a significant external hazard for an aircraft operating repeatedly at low altitude across a city. EASA requires the consequences of bird impact to be considered at certification, based on an impact involving a bird of approximately 1.0kg, following which the aircraft must remain capable of continued safe flight and landing for Category Enhanced operations [18]. The requirement extends beyond the windshield to exposed structure, propulsion units and internal equipment, and covers both direct damage and induced effects in which debris from one component damages another. Multiple simultaneous strikes are considered, since many eVTOL designs employ several separate lift units.
The hazard is acute for SkyCoach. Fixed loops require the same airspace to be traversed repeatedly each day, so any route passing near a park, river or lake accumulates cumulative exposure. Airports manage bird activity by modifying vegetation, removing standing water and deploying deterrents, all of which assume control of the land beneath the flight path. An urban operator does not hold that control.
Two measures follow. At aircraft level, forward-facing structures and lift unit mountings shall be substantiated against the 1.0kg criterion by gas-cannon impact testing using density blocks and by finite element simulation of impact forces [36]. Test conditions shall correspond to the SkyCoach operating speed, since published programmes using birds of 1.5 to 8lb at up to 450mph represent large transport aircraft conditions. At network level, route design shall treat bird activity as a planning input, avoiding corridors above major habitats where alignment permits, with radar-derived bird movement data informing route and schedule adjustment [35]. Enhanced conspicuity lighting provides a low-cost supplementary measure.
Figure 10. Pneumatic cannon arrangement for bird strike and projectile impact testing [36].
4.4.6 Weather and icing
Small eVTOL aircraft are disproportionately affected by wind, turbulence, heavy precipitation, low visibility and icing. NASA identifies icing as a significant AAM safety issue and notes that aircraft not intended for flight in known icing may be required to demonstrate safe handling of an inadvertent encounter. For a scheduled service the matter presents a reliability problem in addition to a safety problem, since a service that suspends operation in adverse weather cannot function as public transport. Weather minima and the surface fallback arrangements at each hub therefore constitute a service design requirement.
4.4.7 Collision avoidance and airspace integration
Frequent operation above cities requires coexistence with helicopters, conventional aircraft, drones and other AAM vehicles, and NASA research addresses the integration of electric air taxis into the national airspace system. The SkyCoach fixed-loop concept assists in this respect, since fixed, published and repeated routes approximate an existing airspace structure more closely than on-demand routing and are therefore more readily separated and sequenced. The corresponding limitation is that route changes become an airspace matter and reduce network flexibility.
4.4.8 Principal risks
| Hazard | Effect | Mitigation | Requirement |
| Lift unit failure | Loss of control authority | Redundant lift units; independent cruise path | P1, M1 |
| Emergency landing | Occupant injury; obstructed egress | Per-module restraint and egress certification | C1, C2 |
| Cargo module displacement | Secondary injury to occupants | Retention at emergency landing load factors | C1 |
| Hydrogen release or fire | Cabin or hub fire | Ambient-pressure storage; isolated bays; detection | E1 |
| Bird strike | Damage to lift units or structure | 1.0kg substantiation; route planning; radar data | S1, N1 |
| Icing or severe weather | Service suspension | Published minima; surface fallback at each hub | F1, I1 |
| Airspace conflict | Mid-air collision | Fixed published corridors; sequencing at hubs | M1, F1 |
Table 5. Principal hazards and mitigations.
4.5 Cabin design, comfort and accessibility (TA, AR)
4.5.1 Design familiarity
Transport concepts are adopted more readily where they present familiar cues. The literature on design familiarity indicates that continuity with an established vehicle category reduces perceived novelty and supports adoption [24]. A SkyCoach interior resembling a metro carriage or an aircraft cabin therefore imposes a lower cognitive demand on a first-time passenger.
The EU-funded CASTLE project used three-dimensional virtual reality mock-ups of alternative cabin interiors to evaluate passenger wellbeing [25]. The method suits a concept at this stage, since layouts may be compared before hardware exists.
4.5.2 Seating layout
Two established layouts were compared. Airline-style rows with a central aisle are forward-facing, which reduces motion sickness risk, provides greater perceived privacy and accommodates tables and seat-back equipment. They board slowly and consume greater floor area per passenger. Metro-style longitudinal benches board quickly and achieve higher density. They seat passengers transverse to the direction of travel, which is a recognised aggravator of motion sickness, provide less personal space and are less readily modified [26].
| Criterion | Airline rows | Metro benches | Mixed modular |
| Passenger density | Unfavourable | Favourable | Neutral |
| Boarding time (T1) | Unfavourable | Favourable | Neutral |
| Motion sickness risk | Favourable | Unfavourable | Favourable |
| Accessibility | Neutral | Favourable | Favourable |
| Compatibility with modular concept | Neutral | Neutral | Favourable |
| Verdict | Rejected alone | Rejected alone | Selected |
Table 6. Seating layout trade study.
The modular concept permits both layouts to be adopted, making the selection a scheduling variable. Longitudinal bench modules are specified for peak-period high-density operation on short sectors restricted by boarding time. Forward-facing row modules are specified for longer sectors and off-peak services where comfort governs. Both configurations are offered through the application under requirement D1, permitting a passenger susceptible to motion sickness to select a forward-facing configuration and to await the coach carrying one.
4.5.3 Motion sickness and ride comfort
An eVTOL manoeuvring in an urban environment applies higher accelerations than surface transport, and research indicates that such motion is unfamiliar and physically demanding for untrained occupants [27]. Motion sickness occurs in established transport modes, and a higher incidence should be anticipated in a novel mode. Four mitigations are specified.
- Headrests with U-shaped lateral support, reducing the neck motion associated with discomfort under lateral and vertical accelerations.
- Seat suspension with passive vibration control, in which a damper absorbs turbulence-induced vibration and may be tuned to attenuate the vertical transients characteristic of the vertical flight phases [28].
- Artificial horizon displays synchronised to aircraft motion. Loss of visual horizon reference aggravates motion sickness, and restoration of a stable reference has been shown to reduce it [29]. The provision is significant in a modular cabin, where interior modules may have limited external visibility.
- Anticipatory ambient lighting, in which cabin illumination shifts to signal imminent motion. Such human-machine interface cues have been shown to reduce motion sickness in trials [30] and convey information without requiring the passenger to attend to a display.
Figure 11. Passive seat suspension arrangement showing damper placement [28].
Figure 12. Anticipatory ambient lighting concept [30].
4.5.4 The accessible module
Step-free access constitutes one of the three defined module configurations, and requirement A1 commits the operator to its availability at a bounded interval without prior notice. The accessible module provides an integral ramp at the entrance, wheelchair spaces with appropriate restraint and the call mechanism identified at HTA task 14.7.1, which alerts the onboard attendant and deploys the ramp. Occupant protection for a restrained wheelchair user under emergency landing load factors presents a demanding certification case and is identified in Section 5 as requiring dedicated work.
Common cabin provisions across all modules comprise an emergency call point at each entrance, two glass breaking hammers and a seat for the onboard attendant adjacent to the forward entrance.
4.5.5 The cargo module
The cargo configuration permits the same loop to carry freight during off-peak periods, improving asset utilisation without alteration to the schedule. Its design is governed by the retention and fire provisions of Section 4.4.3 and by the requirement that a cargo module present the same mass and interface envelope as a passenger module, so that Mo1 interchangeability is preserved.
4.6 Public acceptance and fare (AR)
4.6.1 Crewing and passenger trust
Requirement P1 specifies supervised autonomy with one non-pilot attendant on board and a ground-based operator able to intervene. Two considerations support the retention of a human on board without requiring that person to hold a pilot qualification. First, a public transport service carries unbriefed passengers who require assistance for reasons unrelated to flight, including illness, distress, disorientation and requests for the accessible ramp, and HTA branches 12.3 and 12.4 allocate these to a crew response. Second, the evacuation case in Section 4.4.3 assumes crew-directed disembarkation, which requires a crew member to be present. Neither consideration concerns flight competence.
The arrangement retains one cabin position at a cost of approximately one passenger-equivalent per coach. Its acceptability requires testing against the published survey literature on trust in autonomous air transport. That evidence was not gathered within this study and is identified as further work.
4.6.2 Fare and willingness to pay
Fare level constitutes the principal determinant of routine use. A service saving 30 minutes at several times the metro fare would be used occasionally and would not establish a habitual market, and the classification of SkyCoach as public transport depends on fare comparability with existing modes.
Fare per passenger is calculated as total cost per loop divided by passengers carried per loop. Cost per loop comprises energy, crew, maintenance and infrastructure amortisation. Passengers per loop is the product of coach capacity C2, load factor and services per hour under F1. The formulation identifies three levers, of which load factor and frequency belong to the operating concept and energy efficiency to the vehicle. The module system acts directly on load factor by matching configuration to demand. Assumptions and a worked illustrative case are provided in Appendix D. The figures presented there are placeholders ‡ pending cost data.
4.7 Concept consistency and principal constraints (AR)
The five subsystem studies were conducted in parallel, and four matters required resolution before the concept could be stated as a whole.
Capacity. The comparator aircraft constrain module capacity and do not constrain coach capacity. The passenger equivalent unit and the module-coach distinction resolve the apparent conflict between a four-passenger benchmark and a high-density cabin, and produce the interchangeability requirement Mo1.
Architecture against performance. Requirements S1 and R1 derive from the passenger journey and were treated as binding, while architectural simplicity constitutes a secondary consideration. Lift-plus-cruise was adopted accordingly.
Energy against turnaround. Cartridge exchange decouples turnaround from charge rate, so requirement T1 is satisfied with margin and requirement Mo1 is achievable within the same ground operation. The battery charging benchmark is retained as a comparison case only.
Crewing. Supervised autonomy with one non-pilot attendant was adopted, as set out in Section 4.6.1. Two constraints arise at concept level. First, the binding constraint on the concept is hub throughput. Requirement F1 at a ten-minute headway with T1 at 15 minutes requires more than one ground position per hub per loop. Each position must accommodate module exchange and cartridge exchange, and each must satisfy the ground fire provisions established in Section 4.4.4. On a rooftop site above an operating station, footprint, structural loading and fire separation therefore constitute the governing design problem. No contributor was assigned to this subject, and it represents the principal gap in the present study. Second, the fixed-loop operating concept contributes to three results established independently in Sections 4.4.5, 4.4.7 and 4.6.2. It renders airspace integration tractable through published corridors, renders bird-strike exposure predictable and therefore manageable through route design, and permits load factor to be improved through the module matching system.
5. Conclusions (AR)
SkyCoach is a scheduled, modular eVTOL transport concept intended to serve medium-range urban journeys of 20 to 50km, operating on fixed loops between hubs located above existing public transport interchanges. This study derived its requirements from a hierarchical task analysis of the passenger journey and assessed them against published regulatory, agency and peer-reviewed sources.
Against objective 1, a register of 14 system-level requirements was produced, each traceable to a HTA task and each benchmarked externally. The register extends beyond aircraft performance to include headway, module interchangeability, accessibility, intermodal siting and passenger information, which together define the concept as a scheduled transport system.
Against objective 2, lift-plus-cruise distributed electric propulsion was selected. The multicopter architecture cannot achieve the cruise speed and range required by the mission, since a wingless configuration incurs the hover order energy penalty throughout flight.
Against objective 3, a hydrogen fuel cell with solid-state hydride cartridge storage was selected, on a criterion weighting lifecycle emissions and long-term potential above near-term readiness. The operational consequence exceeds the energetic consequence in significance, since cartridge exchange removes charge rate from the turnaround calculation and thereby supports a ten-minute headway.
Against objective 4, Category Enhanced was adopted as the certification target. The modular cabin was found to complicate the demonstration of occupant protection, since restraint, mass retention and egress must remain valid across every permitted module combination. Bird strike was identified as a distinctively urban hazard for which the fixed-loop concept constitutes both the aggravating factor and the means of mitigation.
Against objective 5, a mixed modular cabin was specified, comprising longitudinal bench modules for peak high density operation and forward-facing row modules for longer and off-peak sectors, together with four motion sickness mitigations and an accessible module guaranteed at a bounded interval without prior notice.
Against objective 6, fare competitiveness was identified as the principal barrier to routine use, and crewing was resolved to supervised autonomy with one onboard attendant on grounds of passenger assistance and evacuation.
Four dependencies determine the viability of the concept. Solid-state hydrogen storage must mature, failing which the concept reverts to batteries with an extended headway and reduced sector length. Hub throughput on constrained rooftop sites must be shown to support the required headway with the required fire separation, and this constitutes the principal unexamined element of the study. A certification basis for scheduled passenger operations above dense urban areas does not currently exist. The fare must be shown to lie within a small multiple of existing metro fares, which the present cost structure can express but cannot yet evaluate. Further work should address, in order of priority: a hub capacity and structural feasibility study for a representative rooftop interchange; a bottom-up operating cost model using measured energy, maintenance and infrastructure data; an occupant protection case for the accessible module under emergency landing load factors; and a review of published willingness-to-pay and autonomy-acceptance survey evidence.
6. References
[1] NASA Technical Reports Server, “Urban Air Mobility Operational Concept (OpsCon) Passenger-Carrying Operations,” 2020. [Online]. Available: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205001587
[2] NASA Technical Reports Server, “UAM Vision Concept of Operations (ConOps) UAM Maturity Level 4,” 2020. [Online]. Available: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20205011091
[3] Federal Aviation Administration, “Advanced Air Mobility / Air Taxis.” [Online]. Available: https://www.faa.gov/air-taxis
[4] Federal Aviation Administration, “Advanced Air Mobility Implementation Plan,” 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.faa.gov/air-taxis/implementation-plan
[5] Joby Aviation, “Technology / Aircraft Specifications,” 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.jobyaviation.com/technology
[6] Archer Aviation, “Archer’s Airworthiness Criteria for its Midnight Aircraft Published in Federal Register,” 2022. [Online]. Available: https://investors.archer.com/news/news-details/2022/
[7] NASA, “Advanced Air Mobility Aims to Shorten Travel Time.” [Online]. Available: https://www.nasa.gov/aeronautics/advanced-air-mobility-aims-to-shorten-travel-time/
[8] NASA Technical Reports Server, “High-Density Automated Vertiport Concept of Operations,” 2021. [Online]. Available: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20210016168
[9] Federal Aviation Administration, “National Aviation Research Plan 2025–2029,” 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/NARP-2025-2029-with-letters_0.pdf
[10] NASA Technical Reports Server, “Factors that Influence Community’s Acceptance of Noise: An Introduction for Urban Air Mobility,” 2019. [Online]. Available: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/20190032256
[11] Federal Aviation Administration, “FAA Issues Implementation Plan Outlining Steps to Usher in Advanced Air Mobility,” 2023. [Online]. Available: https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/
[12] Federal Aviation Administration, “Powered Lift Part 194 SFAR Frequently Asked Questions.” [Online]. Available: https://www.faa.gov/air-taxis/FAQ
[13] H. Kim and A. Perry, “A Review of Distributed Electric Propulsion Concepts for Air Vehicle Technology,” NASA, Jul. 2018. [Online]. Available: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20180004729/downloads/20180004729.pdf
[14] L. Dai, S. Niu, Z. Lyu, X. Huang, and K. T. Chau, “Challenges and Opportunities in Electric Propulsion Systems for Low Altitude eVTOL Aircraft,” IEEE Transactions on Power Electronics, pp. 1–26, Jan. 2025.
[15] J. Kummer, J. B. Allred, and J. L. Felder, “Hybrid Axial and Cross-Flow Fan Propulsion for Transonic Blended Wing Body Aircraft,” 2012. [Online]. Available: https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:68103025
[16] T. R. Critchfield and A. Ning, “Mission-Focused Multidisciplinary Design Optimization of Tilt-Rotor eVTOL Propulsion System,” Journal of Aircraft, 2026. [Online]. Available: https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:284732967
[17] European Union Aviation Safety Agency, “Special Condition for VTOL Aircraft (SC-VTOL), Issue 2.”
[18] European Union Aviation Safety Agency, “Means of Compliance with the Special Condition VTOL (MOC SC-VTOL).”
[19] W. Su, S. Qu, G. Zhu, S. S. M. Swei, M. Hashimoto, and T. Zeng, “Modeling and control of a class of urban air mobility tiltrotor aircraft,” Aerospace Science and Technology, vol. 124, 107561, 2022,.
[20] Y. Yang, J. Zhu, X. Yuan, X. Wang, and M. Kuang, “Dynamic characteristics analysis and robust transition control of tail-sitter VTOL UAVs,” Aerospace Science and Technology, vol. 145, 108868, 2024.
[21] A. Zanotti, A. Velo, C. Pepe, A. Savino, D. Grassi, and L. Riccobene, “Aerodynamic interaction between tandem propellers in eVTOL transition flight configurations,” Aerospace Science and Technology, vol. 147, 109017, 2024.
[22] B. Yu, Y. Zhang, I. Minchala, and Y. Qu, “Fault-tolerant control with linear quadratic and model predictive control techniques against actuator faults in a quadrotor UAV,” in Proc. 2nd Int. Conf. Control and Fault-Tolerant Systems (SysTol), 2013, pp. 661–666.
[23] Z. Li, S. Shi, and H. Liu, “Trajectory tracking of tail-sitter aircraft by L1 adaptive fault tolerant control,” Journal of Systems Engineering and Electronics, vol. 32, no. 6, pp. 1477–1489, 2021.
[24] A. Greul, T. G. Schweisfurth, and C. Raasch, “Does familiarity with an idea bias its evaluation?,” PLoS ONE, vol. 18, no. 7, e0286986, 2023.
[25] F. De Crescenzio, S. Bagassi, and F. Starita, “Preliminary user centred evaluation of regional aircraft cabin interiors in virtual reality,” 2021.
[26] P. Vink, Aircraft Interior Comfort and Design. 2016.
[27] C. Hanson, S. Ramia and K. Barnes, “Urban Air Mobility Passenger Discomfort Evaluations of Sudden Heave Motion in a Virtual Reality Motion-Base Simulator,” SAE Mobilus, 2025.
[28] A. Heidarian and X. Wang, “Review on seat suspension system technology development,” Applied Sciences, vol. 9, no. 14, 2834, 2019.
[29] D. Tal, A. Gonen, G. Wiener, R. Bar, A. Gil, Z. Nachum, and A. Shupak, “Artificial horizon effects on motion sickness and performance,” Otology & Neurotology, 2012.
[30] R. Hainich, U. Drewitz, K. Ihme, J. Lauermann, M. Niedling, and M. Oehl, “Evaluation of a human-machine interface for motion sickness mitigation utilizing anticipatory ambient light cues,” Information, vol. 12, no. 4, 176, 2021.
[31] O. Alrebei et al., “Advances in Drop-in Sustainable Aviation Fuels (SAF): Pathways, Challenges and Future Directions,” 2025. [Online]. Available: https://www.researchgate.net/
[32] Joule, “Performance and design considerations for lithium-ion batteries in electric vertical take-off and landing aircraft,” 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.cell.com/joule/fulltext/S2542-4351(21)00205-1
[33] Y. Lin, Y. Wang, Y.-W. Ho, J. Kar-Hei Fang, and Y. Li, “Characterization and ecological risks of microplastics in urban road runoff,” Science of the Total Environment, vol. 954, no. 176590, 2024.
[34] iScience, “Solid-state hydrogen storage,” 2021. [Online]. Available: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2589004221010282
[35] Robin Radar Systems, “How to prevent bird strikes on aircraft within your airport.” [Online]. Available: https://www.robinradar.com/blog/how-to-prevent-bird-strikes-on-aircraft-within-your-airport
[36] Element Materials Technology, “Bird Strike and Projectile Impact Testing,” white paper. [Online]. Available: https://www.element.com/resources/white-papers/bird-strike-and-projectile-impact-testing
7. Appendices
7.1 Appendix A – Hierarchical Task Analysis
The complete SkyCoach hierarchical task analysis is listed below in outline form. The root task is task 0, and the analysis comprises 14 first-level tasks decomposed to third and fourth level in the flight, landing and disembarkation branches. Figures 1 to 4 are extracts from the diagrammatic version of this analysis. The plans governing each branch are held on the diagram alongside the tasks they sequence and are not repeated here.
7.2 Appendix B – Requirements register, full version
Table 7 restates the requirements of Table 2 with the verification method proposed for each, the subsystem responsible and the present status. Verification methods follow the conventional four categories: inspection, analysis, demonstration and test. Status indicates whether the requirement is supported by an external source, derived from the task analysis or dependent on values not yet computed.
| ID | Requirement and criterion | Verification | Owner | Status |
| M1 | Scheduled VTOL transport between assigned hub pairs | Demonstration | Systems | Sourced |
| C1 | Module capacity of 4 passenger equivalents | Inspection | Cabin | Sourced |
| C2 | Coach carries 4 modules; 16 passengers nominal | Analysis | Systems | Derived |
| S1 | Cruise speed approximately 240km/h | Test | Propulsion | Sourced |
| R1 | 32-49km typical sector; 160km capability | Analysis and test | Propulsion | Sourced |
| T1 | Ground turnaround no more than 15 mins | Demonstration | Systems | Provisional |
| F1 | Peak headway no more than 10 mins | Analysis | Systems | Provisional ‡ |
| Mo1 | Module exchange no more than 8 mins; any module, any coach | Demonstration | Cabin | Provisional ‡ |
| A1 | Accessible module at intervals no greater than 20 mins | Analysis and demonstration | Cabin | Provisional ‡ |
| I1 | Hub on interhcange; vertical transfer no more than 5 mins | Analysis | Systems | Provisional ‡ |
| D1 | Application shows next matching configuration | Demonstration | Systems | Derived |
| D2 | Visual and audible information; high contrast; enlarged text | Inspection and demonstration | Cabin | Derived |
| N1 | Compliance with powered-lift noise rules; 45dBA cruise target | Test | Propulsion | Sourced |
| P1 | Supervised autonomy with one onboard attendant | Demonstration | Safety | Derived |
| E1 | Hydrogen fuel cell; solid-state cartridge exchange | Analysis and test | Energy | Dependent |
Table 7. Requirements register with verification method, ownership and status.
Four requirements carry provisional status because their targets are illustrative values that have not been computed. Requirement E1 carries dependent status because its feasibility rests on a storage technology assessed in Section 4.3.3 as concept level. These five requirements are the register entries most likely to change under further work.
7.3 Appendix C – Occupant protection provisions and passenger
7.3.1 C.1 Regulatory provisions
The occupant protection, baggage retention and fire provisions cited in Sections 4.4.3 and 4.4.4 are summarised below in outline. The summary is a paraphrase prepared for this report and is not a substitute for the regulatory text [17][18].
| Provision area | Requirement in outline | Consequence for SkyCoach |
| Emergency landing loads | Occupants protected against injury preventing egress under the inertia loads likely in an emergency landing | Restraint design certified per module and valid in every permitted module combination |
| Occupant protection systems | Systems perform their function without creating a secondary hazard and without impeding egress | Ramp, restraint and call equipment assessed for egress obstruction |
| Items of mass | Loads from items within or adjacent to the cabin that could injure an occupant are accounted for | Adjacent-module mass included in each module’s protection case |
| Baggage and cargo compartments | Designed for maximum loading; contents prevented from shifting or striking occupants; systems protected | Cargo module retention demonstrated at emergency landing load factors |
| Failure tolerance | No single failure produces a catastrophic effect for Category Enhanced operation | Minimum lift unit count and arrangement; independent lift and cruise paths |
| Fire and overheat | Means provided to isolate and mitigate lift or thrust system fire or overheat conditions | Cartridge bays isolated; hydrogen detection at cell, delivery path and exchange interface |
| Operating information | Operating limitations, markings, inspection requirements and energy-level information supporting energy management | Cartridge state-of-charge presented to operator and to hub systems |
| Bird impact | Consequences of impact with a bird of approximately 1.0kg considered, including direct and induced effects and multiple simultaneous strikes | Forward structure and lift unit mountings substantiated at SkyCoach cruise speed |
Table 8. Outline of the regulatory provisions applied in Section 4.4.
7.3.2 C.2 Draft passenger procedures
The procedures below are derived from HTA branches 10.3 to 10.6 and 12. They are stated in operating-procedure form and are an output of the design rather than a finding of the study. Task references identify the analysis branch that each step implements.
C.2.1 Passenger-initiated assistance.
- The passenger identifies symptoms of discomfort and evaluates their severity (HTA 10.3.1).
- The passenger stabilises position, remaining seated with the restraint fastened and avoiding sudden head movement (HTA 10.3.2).
- The passenger reduces sensory stimulation, putting away screens and locating a stable visual reference point (HTA 10.3.3).
- Where self-managed measures are insufficient, the passenger informs the crew and accepts assistance, using a sickness bag if required (HTA 10.3.4).
- For service failures, the passenger activates the passenger assistance system, informs a crew member, specifies the failure and follows the instructions given (HTA 10.4.4).
C.2.2 Abnormal situation, including bird strike.
- The passenger may detect unusual vibration, movement, altitude or heading change, sound, or a visual or audible alarm (HTA 10.6.1).
- The passenger listens to crew instructions where available and awaits system announcements (HTA 10.6.2).
- The passenger remains seated in the assigned location, keeps the restraint secure, does not attempt to repair any system and prioritises crew commands above all other tasks (HTA 10.5.1 to 10.5.4).
- The passenger does not act on personal assumptions about the nature of the situation (HTA 10.6.3.2).
- The coach continues to the nearest hub or executes a controlled landing at a designated site.
C.2.3 Announced emergency landing.
- The emergency type is identified and passengers prepare for an emergency landing (HTA 10.6.4.1 and 10.6.4.2).
- Passengers fasten restraints, secure loose items and stow sharp objects.
- Where evacuation is required, passengers begin preparation on the crew instruction (HTA 10.6.4.3 and 10.6.4.4).
- Passengers remain seated after touchdown with restraints fastened, observe the onboard safety indicator and wait for confirmation that the coach is stationary and for permission to move (HTA 12.2.1 to 12.2.5).
C.2.4 Disembarkation and evacuation.
- Passengers locate, release and clear the restraint mechanism (HTA 12.2.6).
- Passengers check aisle space, establish a stable standing position and move clear of the seat row (HTA 12.5.1 to 12.5.3).
- Passengers identify illuminated exit direction signs and take the appropriate position in the exit queue (HTA 12.5.4 to 12.5.6).
- Passengers exit on aisle clearance and clear the exit threshold (HTA 12.5.7 and 12.6.2). Baggage is left on board during an evacuation.
- A passenger unable to disembark unaided remains on board and requests assistance (HTA 12.1.6).
- Wheelchair passengers press the assistance button, staff deploy the ramp, the passenger uses the ramp and confirms they are clear of the vehicle with all belongings, and staff remove the ramp (HTA 12.7.1 to 12.7.4).
7.4 Appendix D – Trade-study weightings and fare model
7.4.1 D.1 Trade-study weightings
The criteria used in the trade studies of Sections 4.2.4, 4.3.2 and 4.5.2 were drawn from the requirements register, and the weightings below were agreed before scoring. Weightings are expressed as a percentage of the total decision and are marked ‡ where they represent a team judgement rather than a value derived from an external source. Any criterion carrying a binding requirement is additionally subject to the exclusion rule stated in Section 3.5, under which an unfavourable assessment eliminates the option regardless of its total score.
| Trade study | Criterion | Requirement | Weight ‡ | Binding |
| Propulsion architecture | Cruise speed and range | S1, R1 | 40% | Yes |
| Propulsion architecture | Hover efficiency | R1 | 20% | No |
| Propulsion architecture | External noise | N1 | 20% | No |
| Propulsion architecture | Complexity and certification burden | P1 | 20% | No |
| Energy source | Turnaround compatibility | T1, F1 | 30% | Yes |
| Energy source | Specific energy | R1 | 25% | Yes |
| Energy source | Lifecycle emissions | E1 | 25% | No |
| Energy source | Supply security | E1 | 10% | No |
| Energy source | Technology readiness | E1 | 10% | No |
| Seating layout | Boarding time | T1 | 30% | No |
| Seating layout | Passenger density | C2 | 25% | No |
| Seating layout | Motion sickness risk | D2 | 20% | No |
| Seating layout | Accessibility | A1 | 15% | Yes |
| Seating layout | Compatibility with modular concept | Mo1 | 10% | No |
Table 9. Criteria weightings applied in the three trade studies.
The energy source weighting places turnaround compatibility above specific energy, which is the decision that produced the hydrogen selection. Under a weighting that reversed those two criteria the outcome would be unchanged, since hydrogen is favourable against both. Under a weighting that raised technology readiness above 25% the battery option would be selected, and the concept would follow the sensitivity case in Section D.3.
7.4.2 D.2 Fare model
The fare structure introduced in Section 4.6.2 is applied below to a representative loop. Every input is illustrative ‡ and is stated so that it can be replaced with measured data. The model is deliberately simple: it apportions daily operating cost per coach across daily boardings per coach, and it makes no allowance for taxation, insurance, overheads, financing cost or fare evasion.
| Input | Value ‡ | Basis |
| Loop length | 120km | Six hubs at approximately 20km spacing |
| Cruise speed | 240km/h | Requirement S1 |
| Hubs per loop | 6 | Assumed network |
| Turnaround per hub | 15 mins | Requirement T1 |
| Peak headway | 10 mins | Requirement F1 |
| Revenue seats per coach | 15 | C2 less one attendant position |
| Average load factor | 0.60 | Assumed |
| Seat turnover per cycle | 3.0 | Average trip of two hub intervals in six |
| Operating hours per day | 18 | Assumed service span |
| Operating days per year | 340 | Assumed |
| Energy intensity | 1.2kWh/km | Coach level, lift-plus-cruise |
| Hydrogen chain efficiency | 32.5% | Electrolysis at 65%, fuel cell at 50% |
| Electricity price | EUR 0.12/kWh | Assumed industrial tariff |
| Attendant cost | EUR 25/h loaded | Assumed |
| Maintenance | EUR 1.50/km | Assumed |
| Coach capital | EUR 2.5 M over 10 years | Assumed |
| Hub capital | EUR 20 M over 30 years, per hub | Assumed |
Table 10. Fare model inputs.
The derived quantities follow directly. Flying time per cycle is 30 minutes and ground time is 90 minutes, giving a cycle of 120 minutes. At a ten-minute headway the loop therefore requires a fleet of twelve coaches. Each coach completes nine cycles per operating day, flying 1,080km and carrying 243 boardings.
| Cost component | EUR per coach-day ‡ | Share |
| Energy | 479 | 11% |
| Attendant | 450 | 11% |
| Maintenance | 1,620 | 38% |
| Coach amortisation | 735 | 17% |
| Hub amortisation | 980 | 23% |
| Total | 4,264 | 100% |
| Boardings per coach-day | 243 | — |
| Cost per boarding | 17.55 | — |
Table 11. Daily cost per coach and resulting fare.
The illustrative result places the break-even fare at approximately EUR 17.50 per journey. That figure sits far above a typical metro fare of one to two euros and somewhat below a taxi fare for an equivalent 20 to 30km urban journey. The finding supports the conclusion of Section 5: on these assumptions SkyCoach would compete with taxis rather than with metro services, and the classification of the concept as mass public transport is not yet supported by its cost structure.
7.4.3 D.3 Sensitivity
| Case | Change from baseline | Cost per boarding | Effect |
| Baseline | — | EUR 17.55 | — |
| Higher utilisation | Load factor 0.80 | EUR 13.16 | -25% |
| Lower maintenance | EUR 1.00/km | EUR 15.33 | -13% |
| Lower hub capital | EUR 10 M per hub | EUR 15.53 | -12% |
| Battery reversion | 30 min turnaround | EUR 19.95 | +14% |
Table 12. Sensitivity of the fare to individual inputs.
Two limitations of the model should be recorded. First, hub capital is treated as independent of fleet size, so an increase in service frequency appears to reduce cost per boarding by spreading a fixed charge across more coaches. Above the point at which additional ground positions are required, that assumption fails, and the hub throughput constraint identified in Section 4.7 becomes the governing cost driver. Second, maintenance dominates the cost structure at 38% on an assumed rate, so the value of the whole model rests on obtaining a defensible maintenance figure for a lift-plus-cruise vehicle in high-cycle service.
The battery reversion case assumes that solid-state hydrogen storage does not mature and that charging governs the ground interval. A turnaround of 30 minutes extends the cycle to 210 minutes, which raises the fleet required for a ten-minute headway from twelve coaches to twenty-one and reduces daily boardings per coach from 243 to 139. Energy cost falls substantially, since battery charging avoids the electrolysis and fuel cell conversion losses, but the reduction is outweighed by the loss of utilisation. The fare rises by approximately 14% and the fleet by 75%, which is the quantitative form of the dependency stated in Section 5.